Fighting Property Tax Assessments

These days, it’s not unusual for personal and commercial property taxes to rise steeply. In many areas, real estate prices are soaring at the same time that local governments are seeking more money for schools, law enforcement, fire protection and other needs. But while some increase in your property tax assessment might be expected, take a close look. Your tax bill may have increased too much.

What is Your Property’s Assessed Value?

In assessing the value of a property, assessors generally look at the size of the structure, its condition, the land it sits on, renovations, and recent sales prices in the neighborhood. On a periodic basis, assessors conduct re-evaluations. In some areas, only a fraction of a home’s assessed value is taxed while in others, the full value is used.

If you disagree with the value of your property, here are a few items to check:

Simple errors. It’s possible for assessors to make errors in the physical descriptions of properties. They might list a property as being 2,900 square feet when it is actually 1,900. Or records may say your home has four bathrooms when it only has three. Transposition of numbers is another common mistake when recording data.

Improvements. The bill may include assessments for improvements that were never made or are not completed. For example, you are adding a room to your house but it is not yet habitable.

Comparable properties. Do you know of similar properties in the same area that are valued differently than yours?

Special exemptions or credits. You might be eligible for special tax relief. Some states, such as Florida, have homestead exemptions for qualified owners who occupy their homes. Others, such as Connecticut provide property tax credits to elderly and disabled homeowners. Still others, including Michigan, give tax breaks to veterans and those who are blind. Wisconsin has a lottery credit for owners who use properties as their primary residences. However, it’s generally the responsibility of owners to apply for these special breaks.

Unusual conditions. Some properties have features that lower their value, such as a cracked foundation or proximity to a noisy interstate highway.

Don’t assume that any errors you might find are new. The former owner may have been overpaying as well. Just because your rates are unchanged from previous years doesn’t mean they are right.

Commercial Property

When making comparisons of business and industrial property, there are some other considerations:

  • The assessor might improperly classify a property into a category with a higher rate. For example, your building could be listed as Class A (a newer building with superior steel and concrete construction) when it is actually a Class B older building with a wood frame.
  • Check into whether you are eligible for special rates or credits. Like residential property, some jurisdictions apply total and partial exemptions and credits to property tax, based on how the property is being used. Others have a lower tax rate for vacant property.
  • The properties should be truly comparable. A retail business isn’t the same as industrial property and a storefront can’t be compared to a store located in a mall. Unlike homes, which are often built in homogeneous tracts and therefore can easily be compared to surrounding properties, commercial property is considerably harder to match.
  • If you find that you’re paying more taxes per square foot than a comparable, older store down the street, check to make sure that different tax rates haven’t been grandfathered in.
  • Discuss your tax bill with similar commercial operations in your area that aren’t competitors. This can help each business determine whether it is paying too much.

How to Appeal

Different jurisdictions have different systems for tax assessments and appeals. If you think you have a legitimate claim, you should act quickly since many municipalities require challenges to be made within a short period of time after an assessment is sent out. You can generally pursue tax relief in one of two ways:

1. Negotiation. The most common remedy is to ask for a negotiation with your local tax authority. Be sure you have documentation for claims, such as photographs, comparable sales lists, and property records that show discrepancies.

2. Appeals or protests. Many, but not all, states hear property tax appeals or protests based on a comparative analysis. A successful appeal can lower your current and future taxes significantly. You may also be able to appeal past property tax bills and get refunds.

As a last resort, if you have substantial proof of an incorrect property valuation but are unable to succeed through negotiation or appeals and there is a large amount of money at stake, you may want to take your case to court.

Your CPA or attorney may be able to assist you in proving the true valuation of your property and handling the appeal. Many firms offer services to review property tax bills for mistakes and comparatively analyze properties with similar homes or businesses in the area.

Play it smart: You might have a good case and an excellent chance of successfully lowering your tax bill. But unless otherwise advised in writing by the taxing authority, be sure to pay your taxes on time as assessed, rather than risk penalties and interest for non-payment.

Appeals on the Rise

Studies show that 30 to 60% of all residential properties nationwide are over-assessed yet traditionally, less than five percent of assessments are appealed. Of those appealed, the majority result in a reduction of taxes.

However, tax assessors report that the number of people filing appeals is beginning to increase significantly in some areas and the trend is likely to continue as home prices and property taxes reach new heights.

Copyright 2023

This article appeared in Walz Group’s July 10, 2023 issue of The Bottom Line e-newsletter, produced by TopLine Content Marketing. This content is for informational purposes only.